
A single permission prompt is not informed consent, and Italy’s data regulator just put a price tag on that argument: 805 million euros, roughly $887 million.
The Italian Data Protection Authority (IDPA) fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited over the Facebook app on Android. The fine equals 0.47 percent of Meta’s global revenue. The regulator says Meta failed to specifically disclose that it had access to users’ photos, videos and the related metadata.
The feature at the center of this is “Camera roll sharing suggestions.” It recommends photos or videos from your phone’s library to post on Facebook. Useful, maybe. But the IDPA says access to the gallery came through one permission request covering the whole app, even though that permission supports multiple functions. In practice, you tap “allow” once and Meta gets broad, ongoing access. The regulator argues that this happened “without obtaining specific consent and without properly informing” users.
That matters because it’s how most app permissions work. Bundle a sensitive grant into a generic prompt, and a user who just wants to upload one picture may also be opting into a recurring scan of their library. Metadata makes it worse. Timestamps, locations and device details can reveal far more than the image itself.
The IDPA also says the feature shouldn’t be on by default. Meta has 60 days to collect “separate and specific” consent, explain what the feature does and how to turn it off, and switch it off by default. That includes people who already approved the permission request. So prior consent doesn’t count, which is the real teeth in this order.
The investigation began in July 2025 after a complaint from the Bolzano Consumer Protection Centre. A consumer group, not the regulator itself, started this. That’s a reminder that complaints from ordinary organizations can still move enforcement. Meta is reportedly planning to appeal, and Engadget says it has asked the company for comment.
Context helps here. Meta is also dealing with a New Mexico judge’s ruling requiring $25 billion in penalties tied to the Cambridge Analytica data scandal. Different cases, same pattern: regulators keep finding that Meta’s data access is broader than users understood.
Will it change anything? A fine of 0.47 percent of revenue is a cost of doing business. The mandatory default-off requirement is more interesting, because it directly changes product behavior. If other European regulators copy the reasoning, platforms will have to split up their permission prompts and stop treating one tap as a blank check. Watch the appeal. Meta’s argument will show how hard it plans to defend the blanket-permission model.